When the quip hits the fan: What cartoon complaints reveal about changes in societal attitudes to race and ethnicity

Susan E. Foster

Abstract


A study of editorial cartoons published over the last 40 years, that have been the subject of complaint to the New Zealand Press Council or the Race Relations Conciliator, Human Rights Commission, offers insight into changes in taste and societal attitudes. Offence can be taken not only over the message of the cartoon but at the way it is visually expressed. The focus of this paper is on a selection of complaints of racism and racial stereotyping which together track an increase in sensitivity to racism in society as well as the changes in the race or ethnicity of the alleged subjects of discrimination. Although the Press Council sets a high bar to protect freedom of expression, allowing scope to cartoonists to express very strong, even unpopular viewpoints, the growing diversity of society, with many new immigrants to New Zealand from countries where there is not the same tradition of provocative graphic satire, is raising new questions as to where the boundaries of acceptability lie. Further pressure on editors is being placed by the immediacy of condemnation via social media of cartoons considered offensive short-circuiting the slower, standard complaint procedures which afford time for thoughtful deliberation. Cartoons are considered to be “Opinion” and, although this visual comment must have some factual basis, their key value is being able to say what in other forms is unsayable. If this means reflecting racist attitudes within society, surely, it is better that such attitudes are expressed in order that they can be addressed.

Keywords


racism; discrimination; offence; editorial cartoons; newspaper editors

Full Text:

VIEW FULL TEXT HERE

References


Brockie, B. (2003). ‘Interview with S. E. Foster’. Wellington, August, pp. 21-29.

Brockie, B. (2014). Personal communication S. E. Foster. July 15.

Brown, R. (2003). ‘Interview Malcolm Evans’. Media Watch, Radio New Zealand National, August 17.

Clark, J. (Race Relations Conciliator, 1992-1995). ‘What’s wrong with stereotypes?’ Pamphlet. Wellington: Race Relations Office, Human Rights Commission.

Clark, L. (2014). Personal communication with S. E. Foster. July 1.

Cook, M. (2012). ‘Africa and New Zealand – Politics, apartheid and sport: 1940s to 1990s’, Te Ara - The Encyclopedia of New Zealand, updated 16-Nov-12. URL: http://www.TeAra.govt.nz/en/photograph/35908/political-leaders-visit-of-president-nyerere-to-new-zealand [Accessed 1 July 2014].

Dally, J. (2013). ‘“Racist” cartoon slammed’. Marlborough Express, 30 May.

Daly, M. (2013). ‘Cartoons no joke for the poor says Devoy’. The Dominion Post, 31 May.

Ellis, G. (2012). Interview with S. E. Foster. Auckland, July 12.

Ellis, G. (2014). Personal communication S. E. Foster. July 16-31.

Gustafson, B. (2000). His Way: A Biography of Robert Muldoon. Auckland: Auckland University Press.

Harvey, C. (2003). ‘Cartoonist drawn into NZ furore’; [1 Preprints Edition]. New Zealand correspondent. The Australian, September 25, p.B.03.

Hodgson, T. (2004a). Paper presented under cartooning session ‘Drawing the Line’. The Press Christchurch Writers’ Festival, September 17.

Hodgson, T. (2004b). Interview with S. E. Foster. Nelson, November 25.

Holland, H. (2008). ‘What makes monster Robert Mugabe tick?’ The Telegraph,

June.

Human Rights Act (1993). ‘61 Racial disharmony’. Parliamentary Counsel Office New Zealand Legislation. URL: http://www.legislation.govt.nz/act/public/1993/0082/latest/DLM304643.html [Accessed 30 June 2014].

Human Rights Commission Newsletters (2012). URL: http://www.hrc.co.nz/newsletters/diversity-action-programme/nga-reo-tangata/2012/09/publication-of-danish-cartoons-by-nz-media-showed-way-forward/ [Accessed 25 June 2014].

Human Rights Commission Welfare Working Group Recommendations (2011). URL: http://www.hrc.co.nz/wp-content/uploads/2011/12/Welfare_Working_Group-_Recommendations_August_2011.html [Accessed 30 June 2014].

Lawrence, J. (2006). ‘Address by Jeremy Lawrence, Senior Rabbi of the Great Synagogue in Sydney’. Australian Jewish Times.

Lowe, R. (2000). ‘Cartoonist unrepentant over crech controversy’, Sydneyside; [2 Edition]. Waikato Times, 15 May , p.6.

Maharey, S. (1990). ‘Understanding the mass media’, in Spoonley, P. & Hirsh, W. (eds.), Between the Lines: Racism and the New Zealand Media, Auckland: Heinemann Reed, pp.13-25.

Manhire, T. (2013). ‘At last, Devoy speaks out on race’. New Zealand Herald, 31 May.

Merriam-Webster Dictionary (2014). Anti-Semitism. URL: http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/anti-semitism [Accessed 19 June 2014].

National Business Review (2006) ‘Dominion Post to publish controversial cartoon’. 3 February.

New Zealand History (2012). ‘The Montreal Olympics boycott’. URL: http://www.nzhistory.net.nz/media/photo/montreal-olympics-boycott (Ministry for Culture and Heritage) [Accessed 20 December 2012].

New Zealand Press Council Cartoon Complaints:

Case 918. (2003). N. Brailsford against The Dominion Post

Case 684. (1998). New Zealand Shooting Federation against the Evening Post

Case 1055. (2006). E. Sloan against The Dominion Post

Case 69. (1976). L. Trainor against New Zealand Truth

Case 393. (1990). African Information Centre against New Truth

Case 416. (1991). D. Cuthbert, National Treasurer, HART against Auckland Star

Case 2067. (2009). Kiwis for Balanced Reporting on the Mideast against Sunday Star Times

Case 1088. (2007). T.F.W. Harris against New Zealand Herald

Case 2268. (2012). C. Morey against The Press

New Zealand Press Council. (1990) ‘The Eighteenth Report of the NZ Press Council’. Wellington.

New Zealand Press Council. (2009). ‘Statement of Principles and Complaints Procedure’ (Two-fold, single-sided leaflet). Wellington.

New Zealand Press Council. (2012). ‘40th Report of the New Zealand Press Council’. Wellington.

New Zealand Press Council (2014). ‘Statement of Principles’. URL: http://www.presscouncil.org.nz/principles.php [Accessed 30 June 2014].

Nisbet, A. (2007). Interview with Susan E. Foster. Christchurch, July 4-5.

Nisbet, A. (2013). ‘Stereotypes ensure quick grasp of the issue’. The Dominion Post, 4 June.

Pankhurst, T. (2011). Interview with Susan E. Foster. Wellington, July 12.

Ramasami, S. (2014). Personal communication with S. E. Foster. July 17-18.

Richards, T. (1999a). Dancing on Our Bones: New Zealand, South Africa, Rugby and Racism. Wellington: Bridget Williams Books.

Richards, T. (1999b). ‘From the eye of the storm: rugby’s power to divide and embattle’, in Foster, S. E. (ed.), Guts & Glory: an Exhibition of Rugby Cartoons. Catalogue, Wellington: New Zealand Cartoon Archive Trust, pp. 5-7.

Rishworth P. (2003). ‘The right to freedom of expression.’ Research paper written for the Human Rights Commission. URL: http://www.hrc.co.nz/hrc_new/hrc/cms/files/documents/26-Oct-2010_10-04-12_Right_to_freedom_opin_and_express_draft.html [Accessed 25 June 2014].

Rowson, M. (2009). Giving Offence. London: Seagull Books.

Seymour-Ure, C. (2003). Prime Ministers and the Media: Issues of Power and Control. Malden, MA: Blackwell Publishing.

Spoonley, P. (1990). ‘Racism, race relations and the media’, in Spoonley, P & Hirsh, W. (eds.), Between the Lines: Racism and the New Zealand Media, Auckland: Heinemann Reed, pp. 26-37.

State Services Commission (2004). ‘Treaty of Waitangi Awareness Research - A Qualitative and Quantitative Study’. Conducted by UMR Research in March 2004. https://www.ssc.govt.nz/treaty-awareness-research [Accessed 26 June 2014].

Statistics New Zealand (2006a). ‘Census QuickStats about Maori location’. URL: http://www.stats.govt.nz/Census/2006CensusHomePage/QuickStats/quickstats-about-a-subject/maori/location-te-wahi.aspx [Accessed 26 June 2014].

Statistics New Zealand (2006b). ‘Census QuickStats about Pacific peoples’. URL: http://www.stats.govt.nz/Census/2006CensusHomePage/QuickStats/quickstats-about-a-subject/pacific-peoples.aspx [Accessed 29 June 2014].

Statistics New Zealand (2013). ‘Census QuickStats about national highlights’. URL: http://www.stats.govt.nz/Census/2013-census/profile-and-summary-reports/quickstats-about-national-highlights/cultural-diversity.aspx [Accessed 25 June 2014].

Television One News (2013). ‘Cartoon prompts call for racism threshold change’. 30 May.

Templeton, M. (1998). Human Rights and Sporting Contacts: New Zealand Attitudes to Race Relations in South Africa 1921-94. Auckland: Auckland University Press.

The Dominion. (1988). ‘Facing real race issues’, September 7.

The Press, News Review. (1998). ‘Drawing fine distinctions’, June 22, p.5.

Thompson, P. (2004). ‘Interview Bruce Petty in “Big Ideas” programme. Australian Broadcasting Corporation (ABC): The Wisdom Interviews’. Broadcast Sunday 8 February.

Tremain, G. (2008). 20 Years of Garrick Tremain Politics from the Pen of a Leading Cartoonist. Auckland: New Holland Publishers.

Tremain, G. (2012). Personal communication S.E. Foster. 30 October.

Webber, M., McKinley, E. and Hattie, J. (2013). ‘The importance of race and ethnicity: An exploration of New Zealand Paheka, Maori, Samoan and Chinese adolescent identity.’ New Zealand Journal of Psychology, 42 (1), p. 49.

Yska, R. (2010). Truth: The Rise and Fall of the People’s Paper. Nelson: Craig Potton Publishing.




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.7592/EJHR2014.2.4.efoster

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Publication ethics and malpractice statement